That city hasn’t had a conservative mayor in my memory. If there was it goes back a ways. Luckily they still have enough districts with R city counsel reps to keep things in check a little bit.If it wasn't for Goshen College I doubt if your mayor would have been a Democrat (with a man bun)
Goshen has always had multiple cultures. However in my personal opinion the last 45 years they have bent over backwards to cater to one whether legal or not. I sold my last rental property there in Jan. ‘19. I go back for medical, church and that is about it.