NY: Christian v James “Vampire” ban on carry on private property

[Alamo]

I tried to find another thread concerning this case, but unable.

As I understand it, New York bans carry on private property, unless the private property owner explicitly grants permission either by sign or personal contact. “Private property“ would include restaurants, shops, and other private property, where the public would normally be invited.

Plaintiff Brett Christian and FPC sued in federal court as a violation of 2A and Bruen.

Judge struck down law and denied State of New York a stay on his decision while they cook up an appeal.

 

[bgcatty]

I almost can’t believe a judge in NY actually read and applied the meaning of Bruen and Heller to a firearms case in New York! Slapping NY in the face denying a request to stay the decision was excellent!
We need more decisions like this!

 

[KellyinAvon]

Jump Street is "you have Constitutional rights" not "you have no Constitutional rights unless there is a sign saying you have Constitutional rights."

OH HELL YES!!

 

[JAL]

 

[rosejm]

Judge struck down law and denied State of New York a stay on his decision while they cook up an appeal.

Don't worry that just means the appeal to reversal by the 2nd Circuit will happen that much faster.

 

[Bugzilla]

Judge: NY Ban on Concealed Carry on Private Property Unconstitutional

District Judge John L. Sinatra Jr. ruled that New York's ban on concealed carry on private property open to the public is unconstitutional.

www.breitbart.com

 

[MrSmitty]

New York has always been a location that I have never wanted to go to, mostly because of their draconian gun laws, and because nothing there interests me.

 

[Alamo]

Already running:

NY: Christian v James “Vampire” ban on carry on private property

I tried to find another thread concerning this case, but unable. As I understand it, New York bans carry on private property, unless the private property owner explicitly grants permission either by sign or personal contact. “Private property“ would include restaurants, shops, and other private...

www.indianagunowners.com

 

[KellyinAvon]

Merged!

 

[sixGuns]

Every time I see "stuff" like this...



"Concealed Carry Improvement Act." Just like the STOCK Act!

It makes me think of that scene in Ozark with Helen. "I'm a lawyer, I move words around."

 

[DadSmith]

 

[actaeon277]

"We don't need more guns on the streets"

Well then, she should be fine getting rid of every security officer/bodyguard's gun she has.
Get rid of all guns guarding government buildings.

Let her go with whatever security she's left her citizens.

 

[JAL]

New York's claim they're "keeping the public safe" is beyond laughable. They're incapable of keeping anyone safe, including the NYPD who are being ambushed, beaten and murdered by illegal immigrant thugs without any end in sight.