The R1200RT is a solid choice, I've had three of them. You may have to travel to get one but they are out there. Look at BMWMOA.org in the marketplace. I looked on cycletrader for 2010 to 2019 within 250 miles and found 13.Are sport tourers out of style, or just not an "Indiana" thing? Been looking for a bmw r1200rt, and there are very few for sale. Want used, 2012 or newer. Been looking on cycletrader, auto&rv, craigslist, etc. Found one at tom woods indy, but it had already been sold.
The 2010-2013 are a good value now because they were replaced in 2014 with the water cooled version.