For me, best to worst: (of the chains readily available near Fishers)
Mellow Mushroom
Nancy's
Hungry Howies
Greek's
Donatos
Papa Johns
Papa Murphy's
Noble Roman's
Pizza Hut
Dominos (haven't tried since they revamped their recipe)
Little Caesars (Pan style only)
Hotbox (Thanks jetmech, I forgot this one)
Cici's
Pizza Inn
Chuck E. Cheese
Those are all chains? I've never even heard of several.
BTW, if Hot Box is a chain (as specified in the title) then they are hands down the worst. I tried that place two years ago when I was in Indy and it seriously ruined my day. I ate less than 2 pieces and felt like dog **** the rest of the day.
One of his best friends is my Ex wife's cousin. F'd up dude for sure. I mean that, F'd up.I know I do not like Papa John's pizza.