Which one to keep?

[Rob377]

So I just acquired these. One will go, one will stay.... but I can't decide which!

Top is a Benelli M1 Super 90 Tactical. 5+1 12ga. zombie blaster. If I keep it, it'll get a mag tube extension for 6+1


Lower is a Colt 6450 9mm upper on a Sabre Defense lower. If it stays, it's getting a Magpul CTR collapsible stock. I might just spring for an SBR stamp and get a 10" barrel so it'll end up looking like this guy

Thinking the AR would be a bit more practical/versatile, but I could use a good shotty too.

 

[wtfd661]

I would keep the Benelli.

 

[Andre46996]

Keep the shotgun it would be personal choice for HD. The pistol caliber carbines are fun and are a niche market, if you can keep both do it, if you have to dump one keep the shotty.

 

[Greenmonsta79]

Keep that Benelli!

 

[fpdcop]

Keep the shot gun!!!!

 

[Rob377]

Keep the shotgun it would be personal choice for HD. The pistol caliber carbines are fun and are a niche market, if you can keep both do it, if you have to dump one keep the shotty.

That's why I'm torn. The Benelli would be a perfect HD gun, while the Colt would be a great toy for plinking, FNS, and could function as a HD gun, though not nearly as well as the Benelli.

 

[MoparMan]

Keep the shotgun it would be personal choice for HD. The pistol caliber carbines are fun and are a niche market, if you can keep both do it, if you have to dump one keep the shotty.

I agree. The shotgun is more practical with numerous uses.

 

[SKSnut]

shotty for home defense/hunting

 

[1032JBT]

Keep the shotty

 

[Rob377]

This is beginning to look like a landslide!

 

[superstorm]

Keep the benelli hd great shooters.

 

[amnate2529]

keep the benelli, it's a shotgun for gods sake.

 

[TRLREDY]

KEEP THE COLT!

 

[HandK]

I would keep both!! I don't buy them to sell!! I would rather walk around broke for a week then sell one!! just my two cents, and congrats on them, they look great, It would be a hard choice.

 

[BloodEclipse]

I would keep the Benelli.

As would I.

 

[baldmax]

Keep the shotgun, I would have said the carbine if it was all Colt.

 

[samot]

even though its only half COLT, i would probably keep the COLT

 

[bobbystoney]

Keep the Colt and sell me the Benelli.

 

[alfahornet]

I'd keep the carbine I just end up shooting my AR a lot more more than my shotgun. I concur for hunting the shotgun be better butter as a practical gun you use , I'd keep the AR.

 

[mk2ja]

I would keep both!! I don't buy them to sell!! I would rather walk around broke for a week then sell one!! just my two cents, and congrats on them, they look great, It would be a hard choice.

Why do you have to sell one!? If there's one thing I've learned on INGO, it is that people almost always regret selling a gun.

I'd keep the carbine I just end up shooting my AR a lot more more than my shotgun. I concur for hunting the shotgun be better butter as a practical gun you use , I'd keep the AR.

I'd keep the Colt, if I had to get rid of one. For one, I think it's more fun to shoot. For two, for home defense, you really want to be using a handgun, not a long gun! If it gets to the point that you need a shotty for HD, whew, you're in deep poo-poo! A long gun is more unwieldy, harder to maneuver, and can be taken away by a BG much more easily. (But you don't have to take my word for it: read Massad Ayoob's "In the Gravest Extreme" and you'll find he shares my opinion.)

Keep the Colt and sell me the Benelli.