I've got one with the 6 1/2'' barrell. Its a shooter. I have revolvers that I dont take out very often because i'm afraid of getting them dirty or putting a scratch on them. I love my Heratige Rough Rider because thats what its for. to shoot. Iv'e had mine for 2 yrs and it still looks new.. Iv'e put a couple thousand rounds through it, not a single problem