Depends if you intend on going to one of the states that does not honor IN but honors UT. I got mine for Ohio and Minnesota but now OH recognizes IN and MN no longer recognizes UT. I will renew when time come just to keep myself covered incase other states get goofy on recognizing one or the other.
You have to weigh whether the cost of getting one is worth it to you or not. It was to me at the time. The reciprocity landscape has changed over the last 10 yrs.
Renewals are cheap ($15) and easy (can be done online, had the new UT CFP within 7 dy, iirc).
With the UT permit, you will pick up DE, NE WA, and WV. Virginia is, currently, in "limbo" regarding recognition/reciprocation of 25 states, including IN. At this time, VA still recognizes IN. So, unless you travel to DE, NE, WA, or WV on some sort of regular basis, the UT permit has no value.
Got mine mostly for travel to Ohio and never went back to Ohio until after they started accepting IN LTCH. Go figure.
Was easier to use the fancy UT printed card as recent firearms training to become a member of a conservation club. I will renew mine if for nothing else than it is another form of photo ID.
Wow I had not heard Ohio started regonizing Indiana. I don't know how I have not heard this before now. Just saved me some money as I was planning to use some tax money for Utah nonresident strictly because of Ohio