Nationwide preliminary injunctions are extremely rare, even among the rarity of preliminary injunctions. There must typically be no other alternative injunction scope possible. They're usually issued to the minimum scope necessary to protect plaintiffs from irretrievable or unrecoverable damage until the case is decided. That's how they're supposed to work. It's always at the discretion of the court.What I do not get is why all citizens do not get the protection of the injunction?
I recall an EO concerning immigration, that injunction was not just for the petitioner or even the circuit the court was in, it was nationwide. Why do we always get second class treatment?
"Let's go Brandon"The Fat Lady hasn't sung yet. It's far from over.
Another interlocutory appeal for a preliminary injunction is pending in the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals after the District Court in the Virginia case denied a preliminary injunction motion (Miller v. Garland, Eastern District of Virginia).
Because those days it takes years to wind its way up to SCOTUS. Ultimately it’s because they don’t give a **** about the constitution and they know there are no consequences,Why does it take an act of congress to stop a bureaucracy from making law, or a sitting president from making law?
Neither can do that constitutionally. Yet today both do.
How is it upheld/enforced when it is not a law made by congress?
What I was taught in school of how our government is supposed to work is not what is going on today.
BINGO!Because those days it takes years to wind its way up to SCOTUS. Ultimately it’s because they don’t give a **** about the constitution and they know there are no consequences,
Why does it take an act of congress to stop a bureaucracy from making law, or a sitting president from making law?
Neither can do that constitutionally. Yet today both do.
How is it upheld/enforced when it is not a law made by congress?
What I was taught in school of how our government is supposed to work is not what is going on today.
Well, that and rank and file who enforce the laws either don't know any better or don't care about the constitutionality of it. We all know that the people making these "laws" aren't the ones enforcing them. They could refuse to act on unlawful laws, right?Because those days it takes years to wind its way up to SCOTUS. Ultimately it’s because they don’t give a **** about the constitution and they know there are no consequences,
The House must originate bills to appropriate money. There are already plans afoot to defund portions of Biden's Executive Departments to put an end to their crap. The success of this will depend on the House holding the line and not caving to the Chuck Schumer's Senate.Why does it take an act of congress to stop a bureaucracy from making law, or a sitting president from making law?
Neither can do that constitutionally. Yet today both do.
How is it upheld/enforced when it is not a law made by congress?
What I was taught in school of how our government is supposed to work is not what is going on today.
F*** the Senate. Stop funding ANYTHING which is not within the enumerated powers of the federal government. Preamble to the Bill of Rights, 9th and 10th Amendments.The House must originate bills to appropriate money. There are already plans afoot to defund portions of Biden's Executive Departments to put an end to their crap. The success of this will depend on the House holding the line and not caving to the Chuck Schumer's Senate.
Although Appropriations Bills must originate in the House, they must also be passed in the Senate before they can go to the Whitehouse. You're not going to get there with the House defunding anything unless the Appropriations Bill that does so gets past Chuck Schumer in the Senate.F*** the Senate. Stop funding ANYTHING which is not within the enumerated powers of the federal government. Preamble to the Bill of Rights, 9th and 10th Amendments.
They shouldn’t have caved and passed the debt limit bill. Everyone kept worrying about a collapse of the government. Of course there was another option. Don’t spend more than is coming in like all of us would do. But no, like always the Republicans knuckled under.F*** the Senate. Stop funding ANYTHING which is not within the enumerated powers of the federal government. Preamble to the Bill of Rights, 9th and 10th Amendments.
They have their own pet expenses they want to funnel money into, so it was always a given they would.They shouldn’t have caved and passed the debt limit bill. Everyone kept worrying about a collapse of the government. Of course there was another option. Don’t spend more than is coming in like all of us would do. But no, like always the Republicans knuckled under.