Nice, good to hear, thanks! Visiting the area soon and really trying to narrow things down.
Looking at:
#1 Greenfield
#2 Avon/Brownsburg/Plainfield
#3 Martinsville/Franklin/Shelbyville
Forget being close to Indianapolis or Bloomington, move to southern Indiana, if you need a large town close you can find more seclusion close to Louisville or Evansville then you can Indianapolis.
Personally, I love the Bedford to Shoals area although it is a little far out from Indy if you have to commute. A friend of mine has a place bordering Crane and he goes down about every weekend.