You assume the Gun Store Employees would know the rules, but not always the case. Last time I got a gun the clerk told me that if I checked multiple Race on the paperwork I would a delayed.
Utah Firearm Permit would work - govt issued photo ID - as long as the name and address are current.
(Fun to use this at the airport when they ask for a government ID...)
I would guess it would be pretty easy to fake one of the temporary paper ids? Much easier than faking a real id. I guess that wouldn't help with passing an NICS check though?
How do the Amish buy new Guns? No Photo's (Graven Image). I know the DMV will issue driver license and ID Cards to them with no Photo for Religous reasons. So FFL Guys, how does that work?
We routinely take temporary paper ID's as acceptable forms of identification for 4473 purposes, SO LONG as the buyer has their original plastic ID with them. This is usually not a problem, as the BMV will give you back your plastic ID, as well as your paper temp ID. The two can be used together to complete a background check. The reason a temp paper ID cannot be used alone, is because your DLN on the paper form is incomplete (the first several digits are X'd out). So we use your old ID to get the DLN. We must write your license number, in its entirety, on the 4473.
Commercial drivers are usually out of luck, because the DMV will not give a commercial drivers license back to the driver... The driver will only get the paper document, therefore they will need to wait for their license to come in the mail. But as for everyone else - no problem.
Keep in mind, any gun store is within their rights to demand any combination or forms of documentation, which they are comfortable accepting. I know it can be aggravating at times, but us gun store owners have alot on the line if we make a mistake.
This came up in a conversation with my ffl recently,he said he would not take it. He just felt that it was safer not to accept them, i just take it as the old " we have have the right to refuse service" and understand why he would say no just to be safe.
Very similar to how many ffl's wont accept a transfer from a private individual. It's legal, they just dont want to.
I filled out my address on a 4473 one time and forgot that I had not updated the address on my license so the guy at the gun counter at MC Sports denied me, rightfully so. I came in the next day with my paper copy from the BMV and was good to go.