I'm planning on stepping outside of my comfort zone and buying something other than Gentleman Jack... This thread is giving me a lot of options, almost to many. Whatever should I do?
Bookers
Makers 46
Noah's Mill
But beware, the Bookers & the Noah's Mill are high proof bourbons (roughly 120 to 130 proof), a little goes a long way. Both of those have bolder flavors than the Makers 46, which is probably closer to your Gentlemans Jack than the other two choices.