Maybe our UN Ambassador can send Xinnie the Pooh a terse email.https://www.yahoo.com/news/china-conducts-live-fire-drills-214612460.html
for those of you who have been on the edge of your seats....here's what china says about the us withdrawal
One group is unarmed, the other armed with the best military-grade weapons (from small arms to MRAPs) ... it makes a huge difference.
Short of genocide, is there truly a path that doesn't lead to failure there? The Soviets were not as restrained as we were, and they fared no better.There's plenty of armed groups that could have opposed the Taliban, and some are. The "legitimate" VP is on social media claiming to be reforming the Northern Alliance, which was the Taliban's biggest internal competitor pre-US Invasion.
I would note we were armed with the best military-grade weapons, as were the Soviets. This was not a military failure, it was a politics and cultural failure. The people and tools were there, but not the will or desire.
Short of genocide, is there truly a path that doesn't lead to failure there? The Soviets were not as restrained as we were, and they fared no better.
I think the conventional war was very winnable. America's war machine is phenomenal at that. I think you could even argue we did win the conventional war in that we accomplished the original objectives of dismantling Al-Qaeda and capturing/killing Osama Bin Laden and then stuck around due to mission creep until we lost. It's when we transitioned into nation building the wheels came off, and killing more wouldn't have changed that.
The Soviets killed a lot more Afhans, both combatants and non-combatants, and the end result was the same. Unless we're going to argue for genocide, I don't think less restrictive ROE would have changed much globally. Locally, sure, and I'm sure the frustration of not being able to do what the military was supposed to do (wage conventional warfare) feeds into your friend's feelings. He was a hammer being asked to do a wrench's job, and that's not his failure, that's where the civilian leadership from Bush on failed them.
If I was stranded in Afghanistan waiting to be rescued I know my main concern would be if the military saving me is diverse enough.
Bidiot said nothing went wrong leaving .
Seriously !!!
What planet is he on ?
Wow. When you're a Dem president and you're being called out by Wolfie, damn...
There's plenty of armed groups that could have opposed the Taliban, and some are. The "legitimate" VP is on social media claiming to be reforming the Northern Alliance, which was the Taliban's biggest internal competitor pre-US Invasion.
I would note we were armed with the best military-grade weapons, as were the Soviets. This was not a military failure, it was a politics and cultural failure. The people and tools were there, but not the will or desire.