I looked at BFG's and Toyo's and ended up buying Goodyear Duratrac's for my wrangler. The duratrac's are the most aggressive looking AT I've ever seen and almost look like MT's but are much quieter than my buddies jeep with BFG's AT.
If you're stuck on BFG or Toyo go BFG but I recommend GoodYear's Duratrac.
Time to buy tires for my truck both are high I like both. What about the mileage.