Sell the Guns in on here, after you have 50 post's (Forum Rules). Or try to trade the Guns on here. Trading at a store won't get you close to the gun's true value.
Stay away from dealers for trading in. Sell on Armslist or on here once you get your 50 posts. Looks like you are on your way. Once you do I live in Elwood and am always on the lookout for a good deal on a new to me gun.
Have to agree with whats been said you take a 400lawn dollar gun in most places lowball and offer way under being around a holiday them thinking you might need fast cash.
I'm not sure about trade valuation, but Madison County guns in Alexandria, and Crack Shot in Anderson are decent shops and seem to always have a supply of used guns.
In my experience Crack Shot has been good to deal with, but they are a little high on price. Now if you take into account that they are local, and good to deal with, is it worth a little extra to support a local business if possible? You bet! If I can afford it, I always try to support local business, so they can stay around. You can't trade a gun at Wal-Mart!
I have went to crack shot several times and usually drive up there and the signs are usually on door ether went on a fishing trip or took the day off after this has happend 5 times im done trying to go there.
theres also a gun shop on the main drag in muncie seem to carry alot of stuff pricey though