The dogs I grew up with, died this past winter.
All 3 dogs together.
From my research and reading it looks like I need to see when USMC might have some pups coming. Malinois look like good dogs but I would fear even with my kids they may be a little too high energy. I had always been told with rotts you have to be VERY dominant, not sure how true that is but because of that I have never considered that breed.
All beautiful dogs, and my sincere condolences. Losing one is rough, 3 in a year...
From my research and reading it looks like I need to see when USMC might have some pups coming. Malinois look like good dogs but I would fear even with my kids they may be a little too high energy. I had always been told with rotts you have to be VERY dominant, not sure how true that is but because of that I have never considered that breed.
That's not true at all. Growing up, we had several different types of dogs. Out of all of them, Rotts were the most laid back.
Of all the dogs we had, Rotts and GSD's were the absolute best ever. With GSD's, we did have to put more effort with the training and activities. With Rotts, not so much. All they need is a couch, and treats.
Lost 2 last winter. The smaller Rott in that picture is still alive, and just barely a puppy now.
Other than your twice as fast claim (which I believe is probably understated), I agree with this. They have to be worked. GSDs also prefer to be worked, but in my experience, GSDs tend to be more capable of taking a day off. Or even a few minutes off. For some people and purposes, I think the Mal is a great choice. For a family dog, and particularly if the owner isn't going to be able to spend a fair amount of time working with the dog and giving it serious exercise, *I* would choose a GSD and that's what I'd recommend to most people looking for a family dog. If you prefer your Mals, that's cool. You and I are different people. We react different to visitors, too, so our needs are not the same.
If as you state that Malinois are better dogs that GSD, why are you cross breeding them? Why not find a good ***** for your stud and just breed pure Malinois?
"Their mother is pure German Shepherd and the father is pure Belgian Malinois."
Post 17 2nd sentence.
...
The pure Malinois is not a good choice for a stereotypical family dog. Especially one with small kids. The Malinois is a working dog (and that is an understatement). They are high strung (not like bouncing off the walls like a retriever 1yr old) but more like just waiting to work and then work some more. The Malinois breed is a better choice for someone that needs a all out working dog.
Good luck finding a pup, and best wishes for a speedy recovery. I haven't be able to find out who my local PD gets their dogs from yet, if I do I will post it here. And I agree GSDs are great dogs.I have been laid up due to a medical condition and will be out of work for a while. I am looking for a dog that will help to work me. A good reason to get out and walk around town or go out in a neighborhood field and throw a ball. I had a GSD as a young kid and have always loved the breed, the kids have their lab mix dog, I want a dog to cruise in my truck and go fishing and run around town with me.
I have been laid up due to a medical condition and will be out of work for a while. I am looking for a dog that will help to work me. A good reason to get out and walk around town or go out in a neighborhood field and throw a ball. I had a GSD as a young kid and have always loved the breed, the kids have their lab mix dog, I want a dog to cruise in my truck and go fishing and run around town with me.
Good luck finding a pup, and best wishes for a speedy recovery. I haven't be able to find out who my local PD gets their dogs from yet, if I do I will post it here. And I agree GSDs are great dogs.
Edited I don't know your medical condition or how laid up you are from it, but have you considered an older dog? There are a few GSD rescues in IN. I broke my leg right after I got my old dog as a pup and yes he made me work, but I wasn't able to get around well enough to train him how he should have been. When he was 3 months old he would dang near take me off my crutches when he saw something.
If you want a puppy, they may have something available also, just giving you something else to consider.
German Shepherd Rescue Indianapolis
German Shepherd Rescues | German Shepherd Dogs
Heck if you want something that will love all over you, chase balls, and just generally make you work, I can loan you an older English pointer..... Or perhaps a 1 and a half yr old lab.... Please say yes.
Understandable about being leery of older dogs. I was attacked by a dog my Dad adopted, no stitches needed but I was lucky. I got a hold of his collar as he was starting to lunge and was still tore up a bit. But he was I found out later a bit psychotic and had a history. The person my Dad got him from had him chained in a room because he had attacked before, and attacked someone that came into the room.... Not a good thing when it's 150lb Newfoundland mix. The Rott I had was abused and was the sweetest dog, the lab I currently have was from what I understand abused and is timid except around other dogs then she wants to be dominant.My condition is nothing really limiting in that regard. I was in the hospital for nearly 3weeks and lost a lot of my strength. I have a clotting disorder and some kidney problems. I was pretty active and getting in decent shape working as a order filler at wal mart distribution center before this all came up. Now the medicines I am on keep me tired and hungry which is not a good combination.
I have tried an older dog before, got a siberian husky that was 1 year old from craigslist. After I got him home I noticed he was pretty nervous and started believing he had been mistreated. About 3 months after I bought him he attacked my wife, she ended up with 5 staples in the top of her head, luckily I was not far when it happened or it could have been much worse.
I did not put him down but I gave him to a single male friend of mine and did tell him all the details of what happened, he has been fine since. Still older dogs from unknown situations make me nervous now.