Best Mexican Restaurant - Indiana

[Fenway]

I like the salsa at Riviera Maya

 

[danielocean03]

I like the salsa at Riviera Maya

It's pretty good stuff.

I love the quest dip at most every authentic Mexican place, that is fairly universal.

 

[perry]

Riviera Maya is pretty good. I like all the tile work in the place. That location they are in has been jinxed it seems; jope they're able to keep the business going -- so far so good.

I think I could take a bath in queso dip

 

[danielocean03]

Riviera Maya is pretty good. I like all the tile work in the place. That location they are in has been jinxed it seems; jope they're able to keep the business going -- so far so good.

I think I could take a bath in queso dip

No joke! Since we've lived in Fishers, that location has been at least four restaurants. I hope that one stays, it's pretty good.

 

[Fenway]

I think the food is ok... I don't think it's going anywhere. Place is always packed when I go lunch or dinner

 

[GunSlinger]

I've been to quite a few of those listed above and they're great but Casa del Sol in Nashville is my favorite...outside of one on the square in Old Town Albuqurque NM.

 

[BiscuitNaBasket]

Armando's on the S/W corner of State & Prospect in fountain square. It is run-down and not popular, which is why I love it.

 

[Bartman]

The wife and I like Agave's in Fort Wayne. I preferred the tamales at Don Pablos but they closed down

 

[Wwwildthing]

***Thread-Jack***

About 5 blocks north of my (first) house in Tucson... Chuy's Mesquite Broiler - 22nd Street & Kolb Road in Tucson -(520) 722-5117 - Home of the "KILLER" Chicken, Five Star ***** Margaritas, Catering, Sports, Karaoke, and lots more!!!

Yummy.

 

[AllenM]

El Rodeo in Avon

 

[Mgderf]

El Rodeo in Lafayette, Beck Lane to be precise, not only has the best Mexican food in town, in my opinion, they were also voted the best margarita in town.

 

[IndianaSigma]

Definitely Cebolla's in Fort Wayne

 

[t_star]

Mi Ranchito in Lowell. Best Mexican food in NWI. And it's nice to have the bartender making my margarita as soon as he sees me!

 

[Caleb]

I vote Garcia's

 

[femurphy77]

All you El Rodeo fans, stay away from the one in Greenwood. We always have a to go container of leftovers when we are done due to the huge portions you get in most restaurants nowadays.

When we tried El Rodeo we weren't even willing to take the leftovers home for our dogs. The wait staff couldn't belive that we were leaving our plates half full/empty (based on your point of view) without asking for to go containers.

El Rodeo Greenwood. . . . .two thumbs down, even if YOU are buying.

 

[fullauto 45]

Anywhere BUT Acapulco Joe's in Downtown Indianapolis. The owners have run that place into the ground. Last time I was there, about 2 months ago, food was terrible. Bland, tasteless, like it came out of a freezer meal.

 

[Fenway]

I'm not a fan of El Rodeo. is everyone in Indiana the same? Wost Mexican I ever had was the El Rodeo at Allisonville and 96th.

 

[darkkevin]

another HUGE vote for MI ranchito in lowell. best messican food i've ever had!!!

 

[DRob]

Joe's ain't Joes'

Anywhere BUT Acapulco Joe's in Downtown Indianapolis. The owners have run that place into the ground. Last time I was there, about 2 months ago, food was terrible. Bland, tasteless, like it came out of a freezer meal.

Acapulco Joe's has changed hands several times since Joe passed away in 1989. Seems like each new owner has taken a step or two backward. The menu hasn't changed much but the quality of the food sure has.

I wonder how many INGOers remember when the restaurant was across the street on the SW corner, now a parking lot. Joe did a lot of business and made a fortune. Rumors are he had another business enterprise upstairs.

 

[Naptown]

Anywhere BUT Acapulco Joe's in Downtown Indianapolis. The owners have run that place into the ground. Last time I was there, about 2 months ago, food was terrible. Bland, tasteless, like it came out of a freezer meal.

+1 How about the nasty salsa in the germ-infested squeeze bottles. Give me a bowl. Gross.